BY
BETSY SHEA-TAYLOR / SUN CHRONICLE STAFF
They're off the hips, but on the lips: Carbs. Everybody's
yakking about them. Morin's Diner in Attleboro is pitching
low-carbohydrate dishes, Stop & Shop in North Attleboro
carries `` Atkins Diet-approved'' products, and bread and
pasta industries are scrambling to shore up lagging markets.
Everywhere is evidence that white-food-restrictive diets
are blazing a wide swath through the food industry. Burger
King will hold the bun, if you ask, and some pizza makers are
revising their recipes.
Meanwhile, L.A. Weightloss clinic is pitching diet plans
that include carbs for those who just cringe at a bagelless
day.
Let the jousting begin.
The first-ever "bread summit'' was held in Providence
last fall to brainstorm ways to counteract a reported decline
in bread use among 40 per cent of Americans.
But last month, the low-carb industry flexed its muscles,
and held two summits to discuss the windfall for corporations
and niche markets. Participants dined on low-carb specialty
foods.
What's a consumer to think?
The flagship Atkins Diet, which has taken the country by
storm, works on the principle that when carbohydrate intake is
limited, the body turns to stored fat for fuel, said Heidi
Reichenberger of Boston, a registered dietitian, nutrition
consultant and spokeswoman for the American Dietetic
Association.
So devotees go heavy on protein -- often meat -- limiting
potato, white bread, rice, spaghetti, refined cereals, even
fruits.
The approach gathered clout Thursday (Feb. 5) when the
government announced that carbs are the biggest culprit in the
ballooning of Americans.
But Reichenberger, who supports balancing calories with
exercise for a healthy lifestyle, discourages her clients from
Atkins-type diets. She said weight-loss on the diet comes not
from foods which are selected but from those that have been
omitted.
"What people need to keep in mind is that whether it's
carbohydrates, protein or fat, there is a role for all those
nutrients in our body,'' Reichenberger said. `` The problem is
the portions people eat. People will think of nothing of
eating a bakery bagel, which has five to six servings of
starch. Six to 12 a day is recommended by the USDA Food
Pyramid.
" When you get a pound of pasta on your plate, that's
another 16 servings.''
The source of calories doesn't matter, she said, it's the
number.
" If my body needs 1,000 calories and I eat 1,000
calories of Hostess Twinkies, I'm not going to gain weight,''
she said. " If I eat 2,000 calories of carrots, I'm going
to gain weight.''
Those who have scored success on the diet, however, are
jubilant.
Special reason
Alex Spurrier, 25, of Attleboro has lost 17 pounds and one
clothing size in 3 1/2 weeks on Atkins. His weight had hovered
at 150 pounds for years, then crept to a high of 217 late last
year, he said.
" One of the biggest changes, of course, is
eliminating foods rich in carbohydrates,'' said Spurrier, who
starts his day with an omelet and sausage or bacon. `` I don't
eat as much as I had before. Hunger cravings are totally
curbed. I eat breakfast, lunch and dinner and I don't snack in
between.''
He's cut out breakfast cereal, muffins.
"I was eating whenever I felt like it,'' said Spurrier,
who adopted the diet at 211 pounds. " If I was watching
television and there was a commercial on, I'd go to the fridge
or cupboard and take some food out and return to the couch and
started eating as I watched my program.''
Those days are gone.
His epiphany arrived on Jan. 5 in the form of a Dateline
television special.
"About a half-dozen people volunteered to try
different diets,'' Spurrier said. " One tried Weight
Watchers, one hypnosis, one Slim Fast, one jogging. There was
this one man who did the Atkins Diet. He lost over 100 pounds
in nine months. After that, I was pretty much sold.''
Powerful allure
The powerful allure of low-carb diets is reflected in
statistics.
Unit sales of dried pasta, bread and rice declined over the
year ending December 2003, while protein sources, meat,
cheese, nuts and eggs, were on an upswing, according to new
information released Thursday to The Sun Chronicle by Matt
Bell, senior director of media relations for industry tracker
AC Nielsen.
The figures are based on tracking of grocery stores, drug
stores and mass merchandising outlets. Such trends are
providing both opportunity and challenge for food retailers.
The Valen Group, a strategy consulting firm, found in
December that 59 million Americans -- just shy of 30 percent
of the population -- were watching carbs. The study was
carried out at the behest of Dean Rotbart, executive editor of
LowCarbiz, which produces a new online newsletter.
" It's huge right now,'' said Daisy Whitney, editorial
director. " It's the area of focus if you're in the food
business.''
Numerous special-interest groups such as True-Carb
Coalition, the Carb Awareness Council and the Low-Carb
Consumers League, have sprung up, she said, and they are now
edging toward consensus on labeling to be presented to the
Food & Drug Administration.
" What can we call low carb?'' she said, " Or
reduced carb?''
No definition
This is also a question nutritionist Heidi Reichenberger
urges the public to consider.
" There is no definition of what low-carbohydrate is,
according to the FDA,'' she said." Company A may use 10
grams, company B may have 20 grams, and you don't know what's
`low' because there's no definition.''
Some specialty low-carb products, she said, were up to four
times higher in carbohydrates than stated when tested in a
laboratory.
" The third problem is the way a food becomes
low-carb,'' Reichenberger said. " It is through use of
soy flour and other soy-based products, but that has as many
calories or more. And if you eat too many calories, you're
going to gain weight.''
Jennifer Nelson is a registered dietitian and director of
clinical dietetics at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.
" I think we're all going to be seeing some
frightening information coming out about obesity in America,
and it will be important for all of us to take stock of what
we personally are eating and how we live our lives,'' she
said. " It's not going to be a diet, it's going to be a
lifestyle that we're going to have to come to grips with.''
Nothing new?
Marketing has always reflected emerging nutrition trends.
Sugar-free soda, artificial sweeteners, low-cholesterol
dishes, organic produce are all reflective of this highly
fluid industry.
Lynn Larsen, a registered dietitian and clinical nutrition
manager at Caritas-Norwood Hospital, urges consumers to watch
out for signs of fad diets -- anything that promotes quick
weight-loss, is billed as a cure-all, requires specialty
foods, limits foods or mandates certain times for consuming
food or lacks research.
" Fad diets grab society, and even intelligent people
fall for their claims,'' Larsen said. " Consumers are
constantly bombarded and don't know if it's a credible
source.''
Larsen concedes that Atkins works for weight-loss, for many
people -- and she's not surprised.
" They've gone from eating anything and everything,
and anyone would lose weight,'' she said. " But we want
people to eat a variety of foods. Fruits, vegetables and whole
grains.''
Mary Gibeault is owner with her father, Dick Flynn, of
North Attleboro's Alternative Market, which does offer ``
low-carb'' niche foods consistent with Atkins.
" I don't think it's that healthy,'' Gibeault said.
" Maybe if it's done properly, but I think too many
people think they can eat all the fat they want. And I think
that leads to colon cancer and heart disease.''
Some people think the low-carb trend has a limited shelf
life.
" The whole move for low-carb everything is just
another retake on the low-fat thing we did before the low-carb
thing,'' said Jeanine Achin of the Attleboro YMCA. " What
happened when they decided everyone had to lower fat intake is
we were inundated by companies with low-fat Danish, low-fat
candy, low-fat muffins. Now we have low-carb candy bars,
low-carb cookies and even meals being marketed as low carb.''
Achin acknowledges that low-carb diets are useful for some
people, but is a proponent of " natural'' foods eaten in
moderation and coupled with exercise.
" It's harder to eat 10 apples,'' she said, "
than to eat 10 low-carb bars manufactured to taste like
chocolate.''